There are currently 3 homes for sale in Bimini Bay. The average price for Bimini Bay properties is $148,300 which is 33% lower than all homes within a 20 mile radius. The highest priced property in Bimini Bay is $155,000 while the lowest priced home is listed at $139,900. Most of the properties available in Bimini Bay are homes . Compared to last month, the average price of real estate in the area has gone down 0%.